The Ethical Implications of Genetic Enhancement in Reproductive Technologies
Genetic enhancement in reproductive technologies has long been a subject of ethical debate. Glenn’s research has explored the nuanced implications of using genetic information to influence reproductive decisions. The central concern revolves around the balance between parental autonomy and the potential societal consequences of selecting for specific genetic traits.
One of the key arguments presented is that while parents have the right to make informed choices about their offspring, the collective impact of these choices could lead to a form of modern eugenics. This raises questions about diversity, equity, and the definition of ‘normal’ or ‘desirable’ traits within a population.
A recent case in Europe underscores these ethical concerns. A sperm donor carrying a rare cancer-linked genetic mutation unknowingly fathered at least 67 children across eight European countries between 2008 and 2015. This mutation, found in the TP53 gene and associated with Li-Fraumeni syndrome—a severe inherited cancer predisposition—was not detectable by standard screening at the time of donation. As a result, ten of these children have been diagnosed with cancer. This incident highlights critical gaps in donor screening technologies and regulatory oversight in cross-border fertility practices, emphasizing the need for internationally standardized limits on the number of families per sperm donor and improved communication of genetic risks. (source)
Furthermore, the commercialization of genetic enhancement technologies poses risks related to accessibility and fairness. If such technologies are only available to those who can afford them, we risk exacerbating existing social inequalities.
In conclusion, while genetic enhancement offers promising possibilities, it is imperative to approach its application with caution, ensuring ethical considerations are at the forefront of its development and implementation.
📚 Read the Full Publication
For a more in-depth analysis, you can access the full paper here:
The Ethical Implications of Genetic Enhancement – Glenn McGee
Leave a Reply